A message from Marc L. Mantia, Review Medicare Benefits, LLC

Medigap or Medicare Advantage — the choice everything else follows from

Medigap or Medicare Advantage? Here is how to actually decide.

This is the question I am asked more than any other. The two paths solve different problems, and which one solves yours comes down to your doctors, your prescriptions, and how you would rather pay.

Schedule Your Free 20-Minute Call

Or call me directly at (314) 724-6590.

There are only two paths

Medicare is confusing. That is why I am here — and it is why nobody ever tells you the one thing that makes it simpler.

There are two paths. That is all. No matter how many plan names and mailers show up at your house, every option is one of these two.

I have helped people in Missouri and Illinois with Medicare for more than 15 years, and this costs you nothing. Here is the whole comparison, in plain English.

Path 1 and Path 2

Path 1

Original Medicare + a Supplement + a drug plan

  • You stay on Parts A and B. A Supplement pays most of what Medicare leaves behind.
  • A separate Part D plan covers your prescriptions.
  • Any doctor or hospital in the country that takes Medicare. No networks.
  • You pay a premium every month. After that, the bills stay small.

Good fit if your doctors matter more than the premium, you travel, or you would rather pay monthly than wonder what the year will cost.

Path 2

Medicare Advantage (Part C)

  • One private plan delivers your Parts A and B, and usually your drugs.
  • Extras are common: dental, vision, hearing, fitness, an over-the-counter allowance.
  • You use the plan’s network, and some care needs the plan’s approval first.
  • The plan caps what you can spend in a year. That cap is the trade.

Good fit if your doctors are in the network, you will use the extras, and a low monthly premium matters more than total freedom.

One thing is the same on both paths: you keep Parts A and B, and you pay the Part B premium either way — $202.90 a month in 2026, usually taken out of your Social Security. A Medicare Advantage plan does not replace that premium. It comes on top of it.
Neither path is “better.” But they do not work the same way in both directions. One is easy to leave. The other is hard to get back into. That part is two sections down.

The whole trade-off, in two sentences

With a Supplement, you pay more every month and almost nothing when something happens.

With Medicare Advantage, you pay less every month and more when something happens — up to a yearly cap.

That is the entire argument. Everything else is simple math with your own life in it.

So stop comparing premiums, and compare total yearly cost instead. The lowest premium and the lowest total cost are often two different plans.

Side by side

What mattersMedicare AdvantageMedicare Supplement
Monthly premium
Plus the Part B premium either way
Often $0 on top of $202.90. The average plan premium is about $14 a month.Usually $100 to $300+ a month, plus a separate drug plan premium.
Yearly cap on your costsYes — at most $9,250 in 2026, and most plans set it near $5,400.No cap needed. The Supplement absorbs nearly all of what Medicare leaves behind.
Doctors and hospitalsIn the network.Anywhere in the country that takes Medicare.
Referrals and approvalsCommon. The plan has to approve some care first.None.
ExtrasDental, vision, hearing, fitness on many plans.Medical coverage only.
PrescriptionsUsually built in.A separate Part D plan. Either way, your drug costs are capped at $2,100 out of pocket in 2026.
How you get inAny enrollment period. No health questions.One guaranteed window when you first take Part B at 65. After that, carriers can ask health questions.

2026 national figures from Medicare and CMS. Your own quotes depend on your county, your age and your health.

Where people get this wrong

  1. They decide on the premium alone. The cheapest monthly premium is rarely the cheapest year. Look at a normal year, then a bad one.
  2. They let their one guaranteed window close. You get six months starting the month you are 65 and have Part B. Inside it, any carrier must sell you a Supplement, no health questions. After it, they can say no.
  3. They check the network for one doctor and stop there. Not the hospital, not the lab, not the specialist they will need in three years.
  4. They never run their prescriptions. A $0 premium plan that drops a drug from its list is not a $0 plan.

The one thing that does not work both ways

Leaving Medicare Advantage is easy. Getting into a Supplement later is not.

  • Moving from Advantage back to Original Medicare is paperwork. You can do it every year.
  • Buying a Supplement after those first six months means answering health questions. In Missouri and Illinois, the carrier can turn you down.
  • So the path you pick at 65 is not permanent — but it is not reversible on demand either.

Good news for Missouri readers: inside 30 days of your Supplement policy anniversary, you can move to the same plan letter with a different carrier — no health questions. I wrote it up here: the Missouri 30-day Medigap window.

Which one fits you?

Lean toward a Supplement if

  • You want to keep your doctors and your hospital and never think about networks again.
  • You travel or snowbird.
  • You have a condition, or expect to see specialists regularly.
  • You would rather budget a set monthly amount.

Lean toward Medicare Advantage if

  • Your doctors and hospital are in the network — and you checked, rather than assumed.
  • You will use the extras.
  • A low monthly premium fits your budget better right now.
  • You are comfortable with copays as you go.

If your honest answer is “I still cannot tell,” you are in good company. That is exactly what a 20-minute conversation is for.

Questions I get every week

Can I start on Medicare Advantage and add a Supplement later?

Yes, the move itself is easy. What is not guaranteed is the Supplement. After your first six months, a carrier in Missouri or Illinois can ask health questions and turn you down.

Can I go the other way — from a Supplement to Medicare Advantage?

Yes, and most people can do it with no health questions. Just know that getting the Supplement back later may mean answering health questions and a new rate based on your age then.

Does Medicare Advantage cost anything besides the premium?

Yes — copays and coinsurance as you use care. But the Part B premium applies either way, and the plan does not replace it. Your protection is the yearly cap.

Do I still need a drug plan with a Supplement?

Yes. Supplements do not cover prescriptions. You pair one with a Part D plan — and going without drug coverage that Medicare counts as good enough adds a late penalty to your premium for life.

How this works when we talk

  1. You bring your list. Your doctors, your hospital, and your prescriptions. That is all I need.
  2. I run it both ways. Every Advantage plan in your county and every Supplement carrier I represent, checked against your providers and your drugs.
  3. We add up the real number. Twelve months of premium plus what you would likely pay out of pocket, side by side.
  4. You decide. Staying put is a fine answer. If you change, I handle the paperwork at no cost to you.

If that sounds like the right way to do this, pick a time for a 20-minute conversation — in person at my Ellisville office, by phone, or on Zoom. No cost, no pressure, and no plan pitch.

Why people let me make this call

Independent

I do not work for a carrier. I compare plans across the companies I represent, based on your doctors, prescriptions and budget.

Local, and Medicare only

Fifteen years, all of it on Medicare, in Missouri and Illinois. You get me — not a call center asking for your zip code.

Free, and proven

No cost to you, ever. Same plans, same prices. BBB accredited, 4.9 stars from 62 Google reviews — read them here.

I got into this because of what my own mother went through trying to sort out Medicare alone. Nobody sat down with her and explained the two paths. That is why I do it this way now.

Not sure which path fits? That is what the conversation is for.

Bring your doctor list and your prescriptions. I will run them against the plans where you live and show you the real numbers, side by side. No cost, no plan pitch.

Schedule Your Free 20-Minute Call

Once you book, I will send you a short, secure form so I can look at your doctors and prescriptions before we talk.

Prefer to talk first? Call me directly at (314) 724-6590.

Marc Mantia

To clarity without the confusion,

Marc Mantia
Independent Agent | Review Medicare Benefits, LLC
Office: (636) 203-5840 | Mobile: (314) 724-6590
marc@reviewmedicarebenefits.com
Schedule a free call: calendly.com/marc-review-medicare
16024 Manchester Rd, Ste 200, Ellisville, MO 63011

P.S. Getting expert help with Medicare doesn’t cost you anything extra. Going without it might.