A message from Marc L. Mantia, Review Medicare Benefits, LLC

For anyone weighing a Medicare Supplement — Missouri & Illinois

High Deductible Plan G: the lowest premium in Medicare, explained honestly

Medicare is confusing, and that is why I am here. High Deductible Plan G pays exactly what regular Plan G pays. You cover the first $3,050 of cost-sharing, and your premium drops to a fraction. Here is the honest trade.

One minute, plain English, no pitch — how the plan actually works.

See What It Would Cost You

Or call me directly at (314) 724-6590.

The honest one-sentence version

High Deductible Plan G is regular Plan G with a $3,050 deductible.

That really is it. The benefits are identical, and both plans are standardized by Medicare. Plan G is Plan G, whichever company sells it.

What changes is who pays first. With regular Plan G, the plan starts paying almost immediately. With High Deductible Plan G, you pay the first $3,050 of covered costs and the plan picks up from there.

Put another way: you cover the routine costs yourself, and buy insurance for the expensive ones. The risk you accept is real, and this page states it plainly.

You are not buying less coverage. You are choosing to fund the first few thousand dollars yourself and keep the premium difference.

The three paths most people are choosing between

These are the 2027 figures, effective January 1. Premiums vary with age, ZIP code and carrier, so treat this as the shape of the decision — I will pull your actual numbers.

Most predictable

Regular Plan G

  • You pay the $292 Part B deductible, then the plan covers nearly everything left
  • The highest monthly premium of the three
  • Very little comes out of your pocket during the year

Good fit if you want the fewest surprises and you would rather pay monthly than ever see a large bill.

Lowest premium

High Deductible Plan G

  • You pay the first $3,050 of cost-sharing, then it covers what Plan G covers
  • Premiums typically run a fraction of standard Plan G
  • Historically smaller rate increases than plans that pay first

Good fit if you are healthy, you have savings set aside, and you would rather keep the premium difference.

The middle path

Plan N

  • A lower premium than Plan G, with small copays at the doctor and the emergency room
  • Does not cover Part B excess charges
  • No large deductible to absorb

Good fit if you want a lower premium without taking on a $3,050 deductible.

One thing not to overlook: your prescriptions are a separate decision. Medigap does not cover drugs at all, so whichever route you take, a Part D plan sits alongside it.

What the $3,050 actually means

  • It is set by Medicare, not by the insurance company. The figure is the same for the high-deductible versions of Plans F, G and J, and it is adjusted each year.
  • Your $292 Part B deductible counts toward it. You are not paying twice.
  • It resets every January 1. A quiet year for your health means the deductible simply expires unused.
  • Once you meet it, the plan behaves exactly like regular Plan G for the rest of the year.
  • It is a ceiling, not a bill you are handed. You pay it as you go, only as you use care.
The part most people undersell: a hospital stay in February means you meet that deductible quickly, out of your own pocket. High Deductible Plan G is a poor choice for anyone who could not comfortably write a $3,050 check.

Where the two plans cross over

This is the question that decides it. Your premium savings arrive every month, whether you use care or not. The deductible only costs you if you do.

The simple math: your break-even is about $292, plus roughly 60 times your monthly premium savings. Below that line, High Deductible Plan G puts money in your pocket. Above it, regular Plan G costs less overall.

If High Deductible Plan G costs you… …you come out ahead until the year’s Medicare-approved charges reach
$30 a month lessabout $2,100
$60 a month lessabout $3,900
$100 a month lessabout $6,300
$150 a month lessabout $9,300

Most healthy people at 65 never come close to the top two rows. That is the argument for this plan — and why it is a poor choice for someone who knows they will.

Here is the number nobody quotes you: the worst case is capped. In a bad year it costs at most $3,050 minus the premiums you saved — about $2,330 more than regular Plan G. Past that point, the plan pays.

Write these two numbers down before you decide: the most you could lose to the deductible, and the most you would save on premiums in a healthy year. If the first number would hurt and the second one would help, that tells you which plan is yours.

The table models Part B costs. A hospital stay uses the Part A deductible instead, which is $1,776 in 2027, so one admission can cover a large part of the year’s deductible. 2027 figures, effective January 1; excludes premiums and prescriptions.

Who this fits, and who it doesn’t

Good fit if

You’re healthy and you plan to stay that way

  • You see a doctor a few times a year for routine care
  • You have money set aside for the deductible — ideally the full $3,050
  • You would rather bank the premium difference than pay for coverage you may not use
  • You understand and accept that a bad year means paying the deductible

Think twice if

You already know you’ll use it

  • You have a chronic condition or ongoing treatment
  • You are managing several prescriptions
  • A $3,050 bill would strain your budget
  • Certainty matters more to you than a lower premium

Neither list is a judgment. It is the same question either way: what would a bad year look like on this plan, and could you live with it?

The strategy most people miss

Because the premium is lower every month, some people put the difference to work.

Treat the deductible like a rainy day fund. Set the money aside, and in a healthy year you never touch it.

A hospital indemnity or cancer plan pays you cash when you are hospitalized or diagnosed. It does not replace Medigap, but for the right person it turns the deductible into a funded risk. We should look at both together.

Worth knowing: high-deductible plans have historically seen smaller rate increases than plans that pay everything from day one. That is a pattern, not a promise, and I will show you the carrier’s rate history.

How the conversation works, start to finish

  1. You pick a time. In person at my office on Manchester Road, by phone, or on Zoom — whichever is easiest. You choose the format when you book.
  2. I do the homework first. Send your doctors, prescriptions, pharmacy, age and ZIP code, and I pull the plans that fit.
  3. We compare, about 20 minutes. Plan G, Plan N and High Deductible Plan G, plus the Part D side — in real numbers.
  4. I show you the honest trade. What you pay monthly, and what a worst-case year looks like on each. The second number decides it.
  5. You decide — or you wait. Staying put is a fine answer. If you enroll, I handle the application and confirm your date.

A lower premium is only a good deal if the deductible is a number you could actually write a check for.

Why work with me on it

Independent

I don’t work for a carrier

I am not tied to one insurance company, and I am not a 1-800 number. I will tell you when the answer is to keep what you already have.

Free to you

No cost, no pressure

My help costs you nothing. You pay the same premium whether you enroll through me or on your own.

Proven

Local, and reviewed

Fifteen years, licensed in Missouri and Illinois, BBB accredited, 5.0 stars across 88 Google reviews. I answer the phone in July, not just in the fall.

I got into this because of my own mother, and what she went through trying to sort out Medicare alone.

If you have worked with me before, a Google review helps other people find honest help: leave a review here.

Questions I get about this plan

Does the $3,050 reset every year?

Yes, on January 1, the same as the Part B deductible. A year with few claims means you never reach it.

Is the coverage different from regular Plan G?

No. The benefits are the same whichever company sells them. The deductible is the only difference, so you are shopping on price and rate history, not benefits.

Is the $292 Part B deductible on top of the $3,050?

No. It counts toward it. You are not paying for the same thing twice.

Can I switch to High Deductible Plan G later?

Not automatically. Outside your first enrollment window, moving between Medigap plans usually means answering health questions, and a carrier can decline you. In Missouri, your policy anniversary opens a limited window. Tell me your date and I will check.

What happens if I have a terrible year?

You pay the deductible, then the plan covers what Plan G covers for the rest of the year. That ceiling is exactly what you are buying. Prescriptions and premiums are separate.

What about my prescriptions?

Medigap does not cover drugs, so you need a Part D plan alongside it. Bring your list — a cheap Medigap plan with an expensive drug plan is not a bargain.

Is the lower premium really worth the risk?

Sometimes yes, sometimes no. It comes down to your health today, the money you have set aside, and how you feel about uncertainty. That is the conversation — and I am happy to tell you it is not your plan.

Let’s put real numbers next to your situation

Bring your doctors, prescriptions, age and ZIP code. I will show what Plan G, Plan N and High Deductible Plan G cost where you live, and what each does in a bad year.

Book a Free Medicare Conversation

Once you book, I will send you a short, secure form so I can look at your doctors and prescriptions before we talk. Prefer to talk first? Call me directly at (314) 724-6590.

Marc Mantia

To keeping more money in your pocket,

Marc Mantia
Independent Agent | Review Medicare Benefits, LLC
Office: (636) 203-5840 | Mobile: (314) 724-6590
marc@reviewmedicarebenefits.com
16024 Manchester Rd, Ste 200, Ellisville, MO 63011

P.S. Getting expert help with Medicare doesn’t cost you anything extra. Going without it might.